Shadow Inbox/blog
Subscribe
← back to indexblog / buyer intent / where-to-monitor-for-leads
● Buyer Intent

Where buyers ask for software online: 16 platforms compared

Reddit and Hacker News are worth automated monitoring. X costs money per read. Most other platforms ban the monitor or carry few buyers. One page per platform.

A
ArthurFounder, Shadow Inbox
publishedOct 30, 2026
read8 min
Where buyers ask for software online: 16 platforms compared

Every platform with a search box looks like a lead source from the outside. Between August and October 2026 we wrote one post per platform on whether you can watch it for buyers: what the API allows, what the terms ban, and how many buying

Every platform with a search box looks like a lead source from the outside. Between August and October 2026 we wrote one post per platform on whether you can watch it for buyers: what the API allows, what the terms ban, and how many buying questions there actually are. Sixteen platforms later, the answer fits in one paragraph. This page is that paragraph, plus one line per platform and a link to the full write-up.

The short answer. Automate Reddit and Hacker News: they are the only places in our counts where strangers ask for software in public often enough to watch, and Hacker News is free to poll. Reddit is the volume channel for operators buying services and tools, Hacker News the speed channel for technical buyers. Add X only for a narrow keyword, because every post read costs money. Everywhere else, either the terms ban the monitor (Slack, Discord, Facebook Groups, Indie Hackers, Quora, G2) or the API is open and the buyers are thin (Bluesky, Stack Overflow, Product Hunt, Threads), so you participate by hand instead of watching by machine.

~3/dayintent posts from 12 subreddits (2.7%)
0.5/dayintent posts on all of Ask HN (1.5%)
16 minmedian time to first reply on HN
26 / 53,310Bluesky posts that matched, none for software

The first three numbers come from our buying-intent window study. The fourth is from a 20-minute sample of the Bluesky firehose on 18 August 2026. Every number on this page links back to the post that measured or sourced it.

Sixteen platforms in one table

PlatformAutomated monitoringGood forBad for
RedditFeeds end 13 Nov 2026; API needs permissionOperators asking for tools and services in business subsBuilder subs: 103 posts, zero buying questions in our sample
Hacker NewsFree public API, no keyTechnical buyers; you see the reply windowVolume: one intent post every other day
XPaid: $0.005 per post readA narrow, quiet keywordBroad keywords, where the bill tracks noise
LinkedInTight API limitsAccount signals on a named listFinding strangers asking in public
BlueskyOpen firehose, no authCheap keyword testing on real postsSoftware buyers: none in our sample
Stack OverflowOpen APIOne well-answered question a weekTool requests, which get closed
GitHubSearch API, two budgetsDev tools: issues asking for alternativesPromotion, which the AUP restricts
Product HuntAPI bars commercial use without askingLaunch-day visibility in sanctioned forumsPitching in other makers' comments
ThreadsKeyword API after App ReviewTesting a phrase list cheaplyEnrichment, which Meta's terms bar
YouTube commentsAPI, 1 unit per callSwitchers under competitor reviews and tutorialsReplies at scale: three strikes end a channel
Slack communitiesAPI terms bar itParticipating in one or two communitiesAny third-party monitor
DiscordSelf-bots and scraping bannedNative keyword notifications, public repliesEnrich-and-email, banned by rule 7
Facebook GroupsGroups API removed April 2024Local and niche groups read by handAnything automated
Indie HackersTerms ban scraping, no APIFounder audiences in specific GroupsMirrors and feeds, which break the same clause
QuoraRSS dead, terms ban collectionPromoted Answers, if you payReal-time alerts
G2Terms ban scraping (Section 9)Weekly manual read of competitor reviewsFree automated switching alerts

Reddit and Hacker News carry the buyers

We counted with the same narrow buying-intent pattern on both. On Hacker News, 15 of 975 Ask HN posts in 30 days matched, 1.5 percent. The median one got its first reply in 16 minutes, and 92 percent were answered inside an hour. On Reddit, 12 subreddits that returned data produced 221 posts in 48 hours, 6 of them buying questions, 2.7 percent. That is roughly six times Hacker News's flow from a dozen communities.

Where on Reddit matters more than how much. All six intent posts came from operator communities such as r/Entrepreneur, r/socialmedia and r/Coldemailing. The builder communities in the same sample, r/SaaS, r/AI_Agents, r/n8n and r/indiehackers among them, produced 103 posts and no buying question. Our subreddit map for 12 niches is the place to start picking yours.

Two caveats. Reddit retires RSS feeds on 13 November 2026 and stops taking new public API requests on 31 October, so a home-built Reddit alert needs a new data source. And speed is the whole game on both: a daily digest arrives after the conversation. Hacker News has its own rules on automation, covered in our post on the AI comment rule.

Volume on Reddit, speed on Hacker News. Every other platform on this page is a way to participate, not a place to watch.

X costs money per read, LinkedIn gives signals instead of posts

X moved self-serve API access to pay-per-use on 6 February 2026 and meters post reads at $0.005 each, capped at 2 million reads a month. The bill scales with how noisy the keyword is, not with how many leads it finds. The arithmetic works for a narrow phrase and fails for a broad one.

LinkedIn is the opposite problem. Buyers rarely post "what tool should I use" there, and the API limits make keyword listening impractical. What works is a named list of accounts and the signals around them, which our LinkedIn intent playbook covers.

Open APIs with thin buyer pools

Four platforms let you poll freely and give you little to find.

  • Bluesky. The Jetstream firehose needs no authentication and serves every public post. In 20 minutes on 18 August 2026 it carried 53,310 posts. Twenty-six matched a buying phrase, and none was someone shopping for software. Full count.
  • Stack Overflow. On 22 October 2026 the API listed 56 new questions across the whole site in 24 hours. The tooling-recommendation tag held five questions in seven days, all at a negative score. Full count.
  • GitHub. REST search covers issues and pull requests, Discussions need the GraphQL budget, and there is no cross-repo push feed. Worth polling only if you sell to developers who file "alternatives to X" issues. API details.
  • Product Hunt. The API is free but must not be used commercially without emailing Product Hunt first, and self-promotion in comments is removed. Its forums are the sanctioned room for the pitch. Rules.

Six platforms ban the monitor outright

Slack's API terms forbid using one organization's data to benefit another, and since 29 May 2025 non-Marketplace apps read history at one request a minute (Slack). Discord's Developer Policy bans scraping and bars contacting users outside Discord with data your app collected (Discord). Meta removed the Groups API on 22 April 2024 (Facebook Groups). Indie Hackers has no API and bans crawling (Indie Hackers). Quora's RSS trick is dead and its terms bar automated collection (Quora). G2's terms ban automated scraping of reviews, and its own Buyer Intent product is the paid route (G2).

On all six, the version that survives is the same: a short list of the right communities, each one's self-promotion rule read once, a fixed time to check them, and a reply written by a person.

Threads keyword search is open after App Review

Meta shipped keyword search for the Threads API in December 2024. Its keyword search documentation, read on 15 October 2026, allows each user 2,200 queries in a rolling 24 hours, shared across every app that user authorized. A query returns up to 100 posts, and a query that returns nothing does not count. Twenty phrases polled every 15 minutes come to 1,920 queries a day, our arithmetic on Meta's number. Meta's changelog shows the limit changed on 25 June 2025, so re-read the page before you size a poller.

The catch is approval. Without the threads_keyword_search permission approved through App Review, the endpoint searches only the authenticated user's own posts. Each result gives you text, username, permalink, timestamp and reply flags, and no email or company. Queries containing terms Meta deems sensitive return an empty array, so silence on a phrase like "killing my budget" may not mean silence.

The data terms are tighter than the search docs. The Meta Platform Terms prohibit selling Platform Data and processing it without consent "to build or augment user profiles", and require deleting it once it is no longer necessary. In our reading, running Threads usernames through an enrichment workflow is that profile-building step. Replies through the API are allowed, with a ceiling of 1,000 per profile per 24 hours in the API overview, and Meta's spam standard bars engaging "at very high frequencies", manually or automatically.

We have not measured buyer intent on Threads. Our read is that it leans toward people talking to followers, where Reddit leans toward people asking strangers. Shadow Inbox does not read Threads, and Syften's pricing page did not list it on 15 October 2026. Before building anything, run your ten best phrases in the Threads search box by hand for a week and count the posts where someone asked for a tool.

YouTube comments are cheap to read and costly to spam

Google's quota table, last updated 8 October 2026 when we read it, gives projects 100 search.list calls a day in their own bucket and 10,000 units for everything else. commentThreads.list costs 1 unit and returns up to 100 threads. It also takes allThreadsRelatedToChannelId, so you can read every video of a competitor's channel without searching at all. Thirty channels polled hourly is 720 calls, 720 units a day. Every request costs at least one unit even if invalid, and each extra page costs another.

The buyer comments follow three patterns, in our reading of them rather than a measured rate: "what do you use instead of X?" under a review of X, "does this work with Y?" under a tutorial, and "cancelling X, any alternatives?" with strangers answering. Old tutorials keep ranking and keep collecting new questions, so they matter more than reviews.

The Developer Policies cap storage of API data at 30 days before you delete or refresh it, bar scraping, and bar automating comments without the user's consent. YouTube's spam policy names identical messages across hundreds of videos as comment spam, and three strikes in 90 days can end the channel you post from. Keep the comment ID, not an archive, and reply by hand. Shadow Inbox does not read YouTube. Syften listed YouTube as a $20 a month add-on on its pricing page on 13 October 2026.

Test a platform by hand for a week before you build

Every write-up above ends at the same check, so here it is once. Take your ten best buyer phrases. Search them by hand on the platform once a day for a week. Count the results where a person asked for a tool or service like yours. If the count is zero, you have your answer without writing a line of code. If it is more than a few, the platform's row in the table tells you whether the next step is a poller, a paid tool, or a calendar reminder to read three communities on Tuesday.

● FAQ

Which platform should I monitor first for buying-intent posts?
Reddit for volume and Hacker News for technical buyers. In our own counts, 12 subreddits produced about three buying-intent posts a day at a 2.7 percent share, and Hacker News produced about one every other day from 975 Ask HN posts at 1.5 percent. No other platform we tested came close for B2B software.
Which platforms forbid automated lead monitoring?
Slack, Discord, Facebook Groups, Indie Hackers, Quora and G2 all ban it in their terms or have removed the API that made it possible. On those, the compliant version is joining a short list of communities and reading them on a schedule by hand.
Can I monitor Threads for leads through the API?
Yes, after Meta approves the threads_keyword_search permission. Meta's documentation allows 2,200 keyword queries per user in a rolling 24 hours, up to 100 posts each, and queries that return nothing do not count. Without approval the endpoint only searches your own posts.
Can I monitor YouTube comments for leads through the API?
Yes. commentThreads.list costs 1 quota unit, returns up to 100 threads, and accepts a channel ID, against a default 10,000 units a day. The Developer Policies limit storage to 30 days and bar scraping and automated comments.
What happened to the separate Threads and YouTube comments posts?
We merged them into this page on 30 October 2026, because they repeated the structure of the other platform posts. Their findings are in the Threads and YouTube sections of this page, and the old links redirect here.
— share
— keep reading

Three more from the log.

Monitor GitHub for leads: what the API allows
003 · Buyer Intent

Monitor GitHub for leads: what the API allows

GitHub's REST search covers issues and pull requests. Discussions live behind a separate GraphQL budget, and the reply rules differ by repo.

Aug 27, 2026 · 7 min